Anime Anonymous: Separating wheat from chaff since 2003!

Akira

Site
Stuff
Wheat

Chaff

Trigun

Adult Swim is great in many ways, don't get me wrong. They show fabulous animated sitcoms like Family Guy and Futurama, as well as lesser-known oddities like Baby Blues and Mission Hill. If fifteen-minute cutout-style slop is your thing, you've got your Brak and your Sealab and that cruddy show with the meatball who talks. And just in case you work the late late shift mopping floors at Wendy's, they play it all again starting at 2:00 am.

But let's face it: the reason most people watch Adult Swim is to watch all the groovy anime they play. I'd say there are about twenty different anime series currently in circulation; they'll play one twice through then go on to the next one. And each commercial
Our hero at his best. Our hero at his best.
break (in between Brak news breaks and snippets from the Adult Swim message boards) they bombard you with slogans and reminders about what their favorites are. This is in stark contrast to most networks who promote all their shows as being equally breathtakingly awesome, but it doesn't mean they're right. See, the shows they consistantly spout as their favorites are Cowboy Bebop, FLCL, and Trigun.

Trigun is almost infuriatingly bad. This is a very specialized form of bad in which a show almost has something you could quantify as a redeeming quality or two, but the designers seem to keep pulling out at the last second. The end result is that the series seems worse off than if they'd had just made it completely bad to begin with. I watched every episode of Trigun, each one more "almost good" than the last, until the series was over and I realized I wasted twenty-six 22-minute blocks of my life that I'll never get back.

Take the journey with me.


Characters: 1.5/6 Hamhams
Trigun is, first and foremost, the story of Vash the Stampede. Yes, you heard that correctly. Vash (rhymes with rash) the Stampede (as in a herd of buffalo trampling you to death). Vash is your typical all-around wanted best gunman in the universe nice guy, master of falling into awkward situations, and tortured by a past too hideous to describe without a two-episode flashback sequence.

Let's try to put this another way: have you ever put chocolate syrup on your hamburger? Right. Well, Vash's special brand of happy-go-lucky and super-angst-deluxe go together as well as a double decker Hersheyburger. His third personality archetype (wizened preachy serious guy) creeps up from time to time too, adding to the confusion. I'm all for a multi-faceted character, but the three Vashes that live inside that crime-of-fashion red coat contrast so ridiculously, and swing into each other so randomly, it's more like watching a madman bouncing off the walls of his rubber room.
From left to right: Queen Mkk'ruug of the Mountain People; her dinner; the spacious void in my soul I feel every time I watch Trigun. From left to right: Queen Mkk'ruug of the Mountain People; her dinner; the spacious void in my soul I feel every time I watch Trigun.
You know, when he's taking a break from shooting people while lamenting about the horrors of violence.

Following Vash around on his idiotic adventures are a couple of impossibly irritating bimbos collectively known as "the insurance ladies". Imagine one day you get into a fender bender and the next day you get a phone call from Geico saying, "Yeah, we think you're a danger to people. We're going to have a couple of bumbling harpies follow you around for the rest of your life. They have calculators so they can keep track of how many mailboxes and stop signs you uproot. Oh, and one of them is an ogre." This is the essence of Millie and Meryl, who have the collective entertainment value of plaster.

Now, I did give Trigun one-and-a-half hamhams, so not every character could have been awful. The one character I ended up liking was Wolfwood, a wandering priest who, like Vash, carries enormous guns but, unlike Vash, has no problem with shooting people. Tragically I don't have much else to say about Wolfwood. In the end, it's only the combined stupidity of the rest of the cast that makes him look better by comparison. Also, he dies halfway through the series, which is kind of like the kid at 7-11 letting you get halfway through your stale roachperch hot dog before spitting in the other half .

Story: 1/6 Hamhams
I'm being very generous with this score. The only reason it deserves a hamham at all is because there is, under the top layers of grime and filth, a somewhat coherent story which, if you're desperate, you could construe as being tolerable. Almost.

The story is "there", more than anything; it's carefully built out of pieces carved from the Anime Cliche Handbook (the ACH! ...if you say it like you're a Tolkien dwarf, it's funny) so as to ensure maximum efficiency without the risk of breaking any new ground.

Gunfight?  Duel to the death?  No, actually, I'm looking for the way out of this embarassing series. "Gunfight? Duel to the death? No, actually, I'm looking for the way out of this embarassing series."
Here's a fun game - try to guess what's hidden in the spoiler text below before you highlight it. (Don't worry; if you haven't seen Trigun, rest assured there's nothing good to spoil anyway.)

The main villain is Vash's brother , Knives. Turns out that he and Vash are really over a hundred years old and not human . One day, not long after Meryl (the short one with the library of Deringers) discovers she has feelings for Vash, Vash is forced to do what he's always dreaded doing and take someone else's life . He spends a few months in gutwrenchingly terrible anguish followed by theraputic soul searching and decides the best way to deal with Knives is to not kill him, because killing is wrong! And it's a happy ending.

How'd you do? Yeah, maybe I was a bit too generous.

Animation: 1.5/6 Hamhams
I see absolutely no reason for Trigun to be as ugly as it is. Were it one of those quirky muddy anime series from the seventies or eighties I would cut it some slack. But for a series born in the late nineties? Come on. I've seen sappy video game fan art that looks more professional than this.

...and with your purchase of our Insane Rampaging Cowboy insurance policy, you get your choice of an Alpine Fresh brand air freshener for your car or...  the mystery box! "...and with your purchase of our Insane Rampaging Cowboy insurance policy, you get your choice of an Alpine Fresh brand air freshener for your car or... the mystery box!"
One of the things that really irks me about the animation in Trigun (and other cartoons that use a similar style) is the use of cross-hatching. Cross-hatching is a process invented back in the days of black and white comics to give the illusion of shading while only using two colors. News flash, anime art guys: Trigun is an animated series that is in full color. You can shade it! Light sources are your friend! This whole series looks like it was drawn on the back of a Happy Meal, for cryin' out loud.

I decided to give Trigun a little bit of leeway because it does do its level best to avoid the manga-inspired panning action sequences I so despise. But then, since most of the action sequences amount to Vash shooting at people and not hitting them, that's worth half-a-ham at best.

Culture Shock: 4/6 Hamhams
Trigun takes place on a world covered in endless desert and plagued with gangs of bandits and ne'er-do-wells. And aside from the freaky big-eyed cat, there's not a lot here you need a thesis in Japanology to understand. Although just because a typical American can understand something doesn't make it enjoyable.

I will point out that, for some reason, inflation is incredibly rampant on this poor economically stunted world. Instead of keeping up with the times, the people have just cut the value of all their currency in half by changing dollars ($) to double dollars ($$). As the series goes on, the bounty on Vash's head climbs up through the thousands and hundreds of thousands of double dollars. No word yet on when the crushed and unhappy people will have to make the jump to triple dollars ($$$) or, even worse yet, the dreaded dollars squared ($ 2 ).


Vash doesn't mind the soul-destroying humiliation of being Trigun's title character, so long as they keep the buffet table well-stocked with donuts. Vash doesn't mind the soul-destroying humiliation of being Trigun's title character, so long as they keep the buffet table well-stocked with donuts.
And that's it, I guess. Trigun at a glance. Anime nuts go ga-ga over this series, and I can't for the life of me imagine why. Maybe they like it just because Adult Swim tells them to like it. Maybe they're gun fetishists. Maybe red trenchcoats are in style now and I just don't get out enough.

Links

In the end, I decided to rate Trigun slightly higher than I normally would have in good conscience. You see, while I've seen all twenty-six episodes at one point or another during various runs, I've never seen them all right in a row. And what do I know? Maybe that makes all the difference. I'll give Trigun the benefit of the doubt, if it means I never have to tune in again.

Overall Rating: 2/6 Hamhams

(Update! 8.12.05: This review generated AA's first ever piece of decent hate mail! Click here to read it, and my response!)

- Brickroad

© 2005 Richard Scibbe | brickroad@gmail.com | hosted by rpgmaker.net